Kumato®

kumato1

Perhaps I should call these Kumato raisin tomatoes!  This is a picture about a week after harvest.  Do you notice how the skin is shrivelling up on some of them?

kumato2

Here’s what the inside looks like of one of the healthier looking ones above.  This is three-quarters of a tomato, after a fourth of it was sacrificed for a taste test.  Notice how the skin tore a bit instead of cutting, because it was so tough?  All I can say is wow, YUCK!  A sort of stick to the roof of your mouth, pasty taste.  What a lingering after-taste!  Nothing I would wish on anyone else.

Okay, by now you are all probably wondering what I am getting on about here.

The Kumato® is a variety patented by Syngenta.  According to their website, this variety is created entirely with traditional breeding methods.  As they explain on their website, they never sell anything but the final product to consumers, and only grown by specially licensed farmers and sold through specially licensed sales outlets (in other words, only very large supermarket chains).  If you don’t buy it from an authorised vendor, it’s not a real Kumato!

So if the seeds are so controlled, how did I get the seeds to grow this in my garden?  The answer is that it seems to be an open pollinated variety, and when you save seeds from the tomatoes and regrow them, they appear to grow true to type.  I got these seeds from Laura of Mas du Diable, and I think she told me her father was the original saver of the seeds and gave them to her.

Syngenta does not actually sell this tomato in the Netherlands, so I couldn’t save them myself.

So what’s up with these tomatoes?

Well seed companies lose money when people save and replant their own seeds, and this is often dealt with by means of F1 hybrid varieties, which don’t grow true to type when grown from saved seeds.  It appears in this case Syngenta has breed their tomatoes to be so totally dependent on chemicals, that anyone who does not know their secret formula of agricultural poisons cannot exactly reproduce the tomato sold in stores.

When I grew it, it was very weak and attracted every disease I normally get in my tomatoes.  I grew it in a container, and noticed the roots did something strange to the dirt to make the water flow through quicker and not be well retained.  The plants were not very productive for me either.

Why was it created?

Well first, here in Europe we have seed laws that restrict the varieties allowed to be sold.  Many people in Europe have never seen a tomato that isn’t red!  This is a ‘black’ tomato (also called purple), and it’s a real oddity.  In addition, there’s probably some marketing advantage for Syngenta to be able to say it’s an open pollinated variety, and especially many gardeners are shunning F1 varieties by now in Europe.

Personally, I’m going back to growing heirloom tomatoes!

Here are some pictures from Rich L.  See comments below.  Click on images to see full sized.

The Doers

My last post about Amateur Foods prompted an interesting discussion in the comments, and a comment from Cynthia led me to a new blog I haven’t seen before Growing Power.

Will Allen, in his first very well written and powerful post, offered a
A Good Food Manifesto for America.  In particular my attention was drawn to this:

Many astute and well-informed people beside myself, most notably Michael Pollan, in a highly persuasive treatise last fall in the New York Times, have issued these same warnings and laid out the case for reform of our national food policy. I need not go on repeating what Pollan and others have already said so well, and I do not wish merely to add my voice to a chorus.

I am writing to demand action.

It is time and past time for this nation, this government, to react to the dangers inherent in its flawed farm and food policies and to reverse course from subsidizing wealth to subsidizing health.

While I have a great deal of respect for Michael Pollan, and he has without a doubt done more to attract attention to the US and worlds food problems than anyone in the last century, he is not a doer.  By far the most important people in the battle to fix the broken food system in today’s world are the people in the field like Will Allen.

This is not the first I’ve heard of Will Allen.  Cynthia, a reader of this blog and someone I have been in frequent email contact with over the last few years told me about him some time ago.  Having interesting information and being able to translate it into a post suitable for publishing don’t always go together, as was the case here.  The same thing is true with Cynthia herself, who is very involved in the food culture of Virginia and a market gardener.  The best I can offer on her is to take a look at her recent comments on the last post.

Next on my list of doers are public domain plant breeders and collectors of old varieties.  Some really amazing things have been created or found in recent years by people like Tom Wagner, Alan Kapuler and Tim Peters in the US, as well as many others.  In Europe people like Lieven David, Ben Gabel, Frank van Keirsbilck and others.  Together with these people are all of those running small farms around the world, have a look at my links page for some of those.  I’m sure there are many others I’m forgetting.  These are the people who roll their sleves up and get their finger nails dirty, and they are all special in their own ways.

These are all the people creating the food systems of the future, and they are the ones we need to be talking and listening to.

Perennial Grains Project

Traditional grains are annual crops.  That is, the land is cleared and plowed, seeds planted, several months later the crops are harvested and the cycle starts again.  This is particularly suited for energy and chemical intensive agriculture, because large swaths of land can be planted in the way, with a predictable and heavy yield, then the following year replanted with the same or a different crop.

Public domain plant breeder Tim Peters is working on creating perennial grains.  The way he’s doing this is kind of interesting.  For each of the cereal grains commonly grown today, he has sought out wild relatives in genebanks and other places and cross pollinated them with modern varieties.  The reason is because modern grains were made to be annuals for the convenience of the farmers, so what Tim is doing is reintroducing some of those genes that were lost in that process.

Why are Perennial Grains Interesting?

Perennial grains are interesting because they have a much better carbon footprint than traditional grains, and require fewer chemicals.

Besides the ground not needing to be plowed every year and the energy savings that comes from this, ground that’s disturbed releases carbon.  By not plowing the ground, it allows it to act as a carbon store.

Perennial grains develop strong root systems, and compete very well with weeds.  This reduces or eliminates the need for herbicide applications.

It’s expected perennial grains will also be more disease resistant than modern grains.

They are also drought resistant and do well in poor soils without the addition of fertilizer.

Potentially, this type of grain will become an important source of food for the world.

A Chance to Participate

Would you like to see first hand what a perennial grain looks like and help in the breeding process?

Tim Peters is looking for people to help him develop localized varieties.  The basic idea is to grow it, then select the strongest and most productive plants to save seeds from, then send these seeds back to him.  Of course you would be able to keep some too.

The first grain to trial is rye, and this trial is starting right now.  Planting is done in July and August, so there isn’t a lot of time. [Correction: Tim tells me that while July and August may be best, in fact the trial can be started any time your weather is warm enough to sprout seeds.]

The cost of participating is US$25.  This is because Tim cannot afford all of the postage and other support costs himself.

Next year other grains will be trialled, but it’s expected far fewer seeds will be available for these trials, and priority will be given to those who have successfully participated in the rye trial this year.

You will need some considerable garden space, at least several hundred square feet (30-100m2).  Perhaps you can do with a little less now, if you will have more space available in the spring.

If you’re interested, send me an email as soon as possible and I’ll pass your details on to either Tim or the project coordinator.  If demand for participating exceeds the available supply of seeds Tim may have to choose people according to the space they have available or if their climate is desirable for his trial.

Food Independence for Independence Day

Roger of KGI recently made a post on a campaign he started to encourage people to celebrate the upcoming Independence day in the US by featuring local foods.  As well as promoting the idea of eating locally, he also addresses the idea of food independence, or food sovereignty as it’s known outside of the US.  It’s a really important concept, and it’s important for everyone living everywhere on the planet.

It’s the idea you are able to grow your own food without inputs or outputs of any kind, and without depending on anyone else for anything.  Without needing to get into your SUV and drive to Walmart to buy lumber, large bales of peat, mulch, sacks of fertilizers and so on.  Without needing to buy seeds from a single source because you grow hybrid varieties produced by a single company.  Without needing to use tap water, because you collect rainwater from your roof.  Without needing to use landfill space, because you recycle all of your own garden waste.  Without using power tools that run on fossil fuels, pollute the air and generate greenhouse gasses.  Without needing money to pay for it all.

Of course few people manage to achieve all of these things simultaneously, but by thinking about these things, doing the best you can given your personal circumstances and continuing to work on and improve the way you garden, you are taking an important first step.

A useful way to think about this is the way you spend money on your garden.  Growing fruits and vegetables should be almost free.  You will need some hand tools, if your ground is acidic some lime and maybe some potting soil from time to time, but everything else comes down to recycling things from your own garden and growing methods.  In the short term other things may be needed, for example you may decide to purchase a greenhouse and a shed.  You may have some specific problems in your garden that need to be addressed, one of the most common is soil lacking something that can be identified with a soil test or other methods.  You may have drainage problems that need to be fixed, and so on.  There aren’t many problems that require treatments or inputs beyond a year or two, and you should be thinking about garden sovereignty after that time.

When you buy food from the supermarket, you immediately find yourself in the middle of a complex tangle of commercial interests and politics. It begins because few people know how to grow their own food today, and in part it’s because food companies have invested tremendous effort into making modern foods convenient and cheap.  It’s a vicious cycle that’s hard to break.  Growing your own food is something that takes time to learn, and this lack of knowledge is really a serious problem.

Nearly all varieties of fruits and vegetables are patented and produced by one of five seed and chemical companies worldwide.  Since these same companies also sell chemicals, and they make more money if they sell chemicals with their seeds, so they breed them specifically to need these chemicals.  We are all familiar with GM Round Up ready varieties, and this is one very obvious example as Monsanto sells both Round Up and the Round Up ready varieties of seed.  There are many, many much more insidious examples of this for example cucumbers susceptible to mildew diseases or insect pests that require chemicals.

When farmers buy commercial seeds to plant, they get a list of required chemicals and a schedule for applying them.  Agriculture by numbers, if you like.  If farmers don’t do this the seed companies won’t support them.  It’s like doing something that invalidates a consumer warranty, even if it has nothing to do with some unrelated problem that needs to be fixed.  Under these circumstances, you can be assured farmers will apply all the required chemicals even if they know they aren’t needed.

If you buy certified organic food, you are still buying these commercial varieties.  In this case, you pay for the patents on the varieties and the work that went into them being designed to need chemicals, the extra trouble the farmer has to go through to grow them without chemicals, finally the very cumbersome associated paperwork and regulations intended to put small farmers and food producers at a disadvantage.  It’s a silly way to buy your food.

If you buy meat, this tangle gets even more intense, because first the grains are grown like I described above, then the animals are raised following similar lines of logic.

This is what we call the Green Revolution.

It came about because during the depression of the 30s and the war years that followed, there were food shortages and they need to ensure food companies who invested in improved plant varieties and production methods could be assured of profits.  They invested in plant varieties, chemicals and methods that made them as much money as possible and there were no other reasons for what they did.  There’s no reason to believe, if they hadn’t instead invested in organic agriculture without chemical and energy inputs, productions yields would be any lower today than they are now.

When politicians talk about providing ‘high quality’ seeds to the developing world to fight hunger, they are lying.  It’s as simple as that.  Instead what they are talking about is forcing a system of debt, dependence and environmental damage on hungry people who are in desperate need of developing their own food sovereignty.

If you go to a garden center and buy a normal commercial packet of seeds, you immediately put yourself in the middle of this tangle of required chemicals and politics.  It’s not that it’s impossible to grow nice things from commercial seed packets, but you’re starting off at a disadvantage.

If you think along the lines of food sovereignty, and avoid commercial seeds, you’re assured chemicals will not be needed to grow your plants.  Otherwise the situation is less clear.

In order to be sure to avoid the usual commercial tangle, if you want to purchase non-commercial seeds, you should purchase them from a company that specialized in them.  The best thing would be if you can find a local company, that hopefully produces seeds most suitable for your local climate.  In any case, be sure to look specifically for a company that specializes in non-commercial seeds.  The links page on this blog lists a number of these companies.

If you grow non-commercial seeds, another advantage is being able to save and replant seeds from these plants.  Saving seeds is also a skill that’s been lost with our current generation and takes some time to learn.  Many people start reading about how complicated it is and are quickly discouraged.  It really doesn’t have to be difficult.  Roger’s post that I linked to at the top, discusses growing garlic, something that doesn’t take any special skills to save and replant.  Beans, peas and lettuce are nearly as easy.  Just grow the plants and save the seeds — that’s it.  Other plants can be more complicated but a little research is all that’s needed to learn how to do it.  You must however start with non-commercial seeds, or the plants you get after saving your seeds will not be the same as the original parent plants.

Once you make the decision to start saving your seeds, you have access to the wonderful world of seed exchanges.  These are fellow gardeners who also save their own seeds, and often have very special varieties of plants on offer.  While some of these gardeners are happy to provide their seeds to anyone and everyone, most really expect you to have the intention of saving and regrowing them, so it’s best to at least have the intention of doing this before getting involved in trading this way.  If you’re interested in offering or receiving non-commercial seeds, have a look at the Bloggers Seed Netork page.

Aim for food sovereignty.  Don’t add anything unnecessarily to your garden.  Get away from the mindset of being a farmer, and needing a box of this and a bottle of that.  Don’t give your money to the wrong companies.  Grow the right varieties.  Take care of our planet and your health, at the same time you grow fresh fruits and vegetables in your own garden.