Link Between Disappearing Bees and GM Crops?

For some time now bee keepers in the US have noticed their bees have been disappearing, the so called Colony Collapse Disorder.

It’s hard to overstate the importance of this problem. The vast majority of our food crops are pollinated by insects, and quite simply without the insects there can be no harvest. Bees are among the most important pollinating insects.

A Pennsylvania bee farmer has a theory why this is happening. He thinks it’s because of GM crops engineered to produce Bt, a naturally occurring pesticide.

I say naturally occurring, because it’s present in small quantities in the environment. In these GM crops however, it’s another story. Crops engineered to produce Bt do so in very large quantities. It’s produced by every cell in the plant including roots, stems, leaves and flowers. It’s also present in the pollen of these plants. The amount of Bt in these plants is enough to trigger allergies in some people, and irritate the skin and eyes of farmers who handle the crops. In India, when sheep were used to clear a field of left over Bt cotton, several sheep died after eating it.

Even if this farmer’s theory turns out not to be true, it should really serve as a wake up call. The genetic contamination from these GM crops has long ago left the fields where they were grown, and if it is necessary to clean it up, it could prove to be enormously difficult. GM contamination is after all the only self-replicating contamination human beings have ever released into the environment.

It’s here!

Seed Savers Yearbook

It arrived a few days ago, and I’m really excited. The 2007 Seed Savers Exchange (SSE) Yearbook, their annual list of member offered seeds and plant samples. Nearly 500 pages, and 12,920 unique varieties of plants. The number of unique varieties offered by the SSE is at an all time high! I have just enough time to order a few last things for the garden…

With the the excitement also comes some more sobering news, a 4% decline in the number of listed members. A listed member is one who offers at least one plant to other members via this annual yearbook. This decline comes after more than a decade of steady declines.

Statistics

With fewer members actually sharing materials, the long term viability of the SSE is in jeopardy.

In the introduction, a few explanations were offered for the decline in listed members. First the popularity of their Internet sales, and the ease of being able to place small orders without having to pay a membership fee, may have caused some of their less devoted members to drop out. Another is that some members have complained that seeds they go to the trouble of offering, are not being reoffered by other members. Since this in itself is a symptom of not having a large enough base of dedicated listed members, the problem is potentially self perpetuating.

Like we have been talking about on several blogs this year, in spite of all the excitement being seen now surrounding growing heirloom foods and seed saving, the actual numbers of people doing it continues to be in decline.

It takes time and trouble to become a listed member in the SSE. The first year you have to become an unlisted member, read the materials and understand how it all works and perhaps order some seeds to get started with. You have to grow the plants in your garden that will produce the seeds you can offer to other members, and if you don’t have a lot of gardening experience learning this can also take some time. It can take two or three years, or longer, before you can start offering plants. It’s important to get focused on the issue, and get started as soon as possible.

In the meantime, those of you in the US, be sure and visit the SSE website and support them financially by buying products from them.

Learning Latin

For people who save seeds or breed their own varieties, learning the Latin names of your plants can tell you a lot about them. For example, if you want to know if plants will cross pollinate with each other, the Latin name can give you clues to this. The Latin name can also give you clues about hardiness, cultivation methods and so on. Scientists assign Latin names in order to group similar plants together.

Another reason for using the Latin names for plants, is it eliminates confusion caused by local languages. When a vegetable is called a swede in the UK and a rutabaga in the US, and you don’t know what to call it when talking to a German speaking gardener, calling it Brassica napus eliminates the confusion!

I’m just going to list a few examples here, for a more complete listing you should consult a seed savers manual or a plant dictionary. There are a number of online resources for this as well.

Latin names contain three parts the family, genus and species. For vegetable growers, the most important families are Amaryllidaceae (Onions and related), Brassicaceae (Cabbages and related), Chenopodiaceae (Beets and related), Compositae (Lettuce and related), Cucurbitaceae (Pumpkins and related), Leguminosae (Beans and related), Solanaceae (Tomatoes and related) and Umbelliferae (Carrots and related).

Lets have a closer look at one of these families, for example the Brassicaceae family. Most plants are referred to by their genus and species, so in the above example of Brassica napus, Brassica is the genus and napus is the species. Here are a few more common examples within this family:

Armoracia rusticana: Horseradish

Brassica oleracea: Cabbage, Broccoli and others

Brassica rapa: Turnip, Chinese Cabbage and others

Eruca sativa: Rocket

So how can you use this information? Well let’s say you wanted to grow turnips next to rutabagas (swedes), and you want to know if they will cross. The Latin name for turnip is Brassica rapa, and for rutabagas Brassica napus. By looking at the Latin names it is not completely clear in this case, because they are from the same genus but different species. Again based only on the Latin names you could conclude that a cross would be less likely to occur with Rocket (Eruca sativa), because both the genus and species are different, but in fact a cross between plants of different species doesn’t usually happen, so growing rutabagas and turnips next to each other would probably not result in a cross.

What about other kinds of genetic compatibility? Rebsie on Daughter of the Soil recently discussed grafting potato scions onto tomato root stock, for the purpose of making large numbers of potato seeds (not to be confused with seed potatoes!). A scion is the term for a branch or piece of foliage, cut in a way that is intended to be spliced to the roots of another plant. Let’s look at this from the point of view of the plant’s Latin names. Both potatoes and tomatoes belong to the family Solanaceae, and the Latin names are as follows:

Lycopersicon lycopersicum: Tomato

Solanum tuberosum: Potato

In this case the genus and species are both different, but being in the same family it seems is enough compatibility for the plants to be grafted together. It’s very unlikely these two plants would ever cross pollinate with each other however.

Heirloom Gardener in Belgium

Lieven David (first name=Lieven; surname=David) in Belgium has been working on a Engligh and Dutch language website for his garden, De Lusthof (Garden of Eden in English).

He has been gardening for 28 years, and growing his own pumpkins for 20 years! He has created many of his own varieties. As well as pumpkins he has many other plants and seeds. On his website he has seeds offered, as well as plants and seeds he is looking for.

He is eager to meet other seed savers! Don’t miss the opportunity to get in touch with him. Contact information is on his website.