EU Seed Laws Struck Down by High Court…(not yet!)
[update: I've been told this is a prejudicial opinion, thus not yet the ruling of the court and not yet a binding decision. Hopefully we'll have a more concrete ruling later.]
Yesterday an EU Advocate-General sided with French seed organization Kokopelli on the provision in EU law prohibiting the sale of unregistered varieties.
In reference to EU seed laws and related French regulations, the Advocate-General said they
“violate the principle of proportionality, free enterprise, free movement of goods, and the principle of non discrimination.”
The Advocate-General said the official seed catalog has
“nothing to do with plant health”
and
“it is up to farmers to decide which varieties they grow”
the Advocate-General added
“the fact that farmers are confined to the listed varieties greatly reduces genetic diversity in European fields.”
Unfortunately the original opinion was written in German, and as of the time of this post had not yet been translated into English. You can read the opinion in a variety of non-English languages here.
Almost all of Kokopelli’s arguments were upheld, and most of the opposition’s arguments were not.
New GM Corn Trial Planned in Belgium
Following up on the GM potato trial that took place last year in Belgium, a new GM trial — this time corn, is planned for the coming three years in the same location! I wonder if they’re going to build a stronger fence this time?! Is it just a coincidence they announced this the day before Christmas holiday weekend?
This time they assure us no one could possibly object to the trial. They say they will remove the tassels before the plants produce pollen so contamination of the nearby environment won’t be possible. They also say there will be no business interests, it will only be a project of the university. Hm, I wonder if the university has any business connections itself…
An important message from the organizers of the resistance:
[EN] Hello,
Yesterday we learned that the VIB is requesting authorisation for a field trial for GM maize in Wetteren. This crop would be launched in a three year open field trial, from 2012 on. A public consultation is organised which is open till 21 January.
It’s very important to respond individually to this consultation by using the special form for this purpose.
Below you find links to useful documents, press articles and a dossier that aims to develop some arguments on this case.
http://fieldliberation.files.wordpress.com/2011/12/rough-reader-on-the-new-vib-maize-crop.pdf
The pdf is just a personal summary of some facts and possible context around that sudden new field trial. To be used freely, as extra inspiration for replying at the inquiry, for an article, an action, or a campaign…
For more information see their website.
See here to respond to the consultation, but be aware as of the time of this post, the English language form wasn’t available. Keep trying! Let’s send some web traffic their way and let them know we’re eager, even before the form becomes available.
Another World is Plantable – Community Gardening in South Africa
I was looking around for other films made by Ella von der Haide, the same person who made Resilient Seed the film about our Brussels action last spring, and I came across this. What a find! This is a really interesting look into Community Gardens in South Africa, and the sorts of problems they face.
Dan Jason and Owen Bridge on Seed Saving in Canada
Thanks to Mike who mentioned these videos in a comment on my last post. These videos are of Dan Jason of Salt Spring Seeds and The Plant Sanctuary for Canada, and Owen Bridge of Annapolis Valley Seeds, representing Canada’s two coasts at a Seedy Sunday event from earlier this year.
It’s really a great example on how in different parts of the world we have slightly different battles and laws, but in the end our overall problems and goals are the same. Here is Europe we are fighting the battle of legalizing seed saving, but in North America they’re not only fighting to keep seed saving legal, but also facing the real prospect of aggressive police action if they are unsuccessful.
Recently some laws were changed in Canada and other parts of the world like Europe to protect the pharmaceutical industry from the competition of natural foods and herbal remedies. This resulted in raids in Canada where unlicensed vitamins were confiscated by swat teams at gunpoint. It’s very possible heirloom seed companies will one day see their stocks of seeds confiscated in the same way.
We all need to act locally and think globally. We should grow seeds in our own gardens that are locally obtained and suitable for our local climate, but we shouldn’t forget seeds can be obtained elsewhere if necessary. In the same way, we should be fighting our own battles locally, but not forgetting there’s a whole world out there with other people fighting the same battle.
Benefits of Gardening
Jane Alvarado of The Pond Blog and Loch Ness Water Gardens sent me this interesting infographic. I guess I’m a little bit of a sucker for infographics, and I like this one. I’m not sure about the making money part, but the rest looks good to me.
Source by Loch Ness Water Gardens
